22 October 2021 The Irish Film & Television Network
     

Irish Film and Television Network

 »

TV

 »

news



New BAI-commissioned report recommends development of robust procedures for reporting and monitoring online disinformation
17 Sep 2021 : Nathan Griffin
Covid Check report
More robust procedures for reporting and monitoring online disinformation need to be developed for the EU Code of Practice on Disinformation to become a more effective tool in fighting disinformation. That’s according to CovidCheck, a new research report assessing the implementation of the Code in relation to COVID-19.

Commissioned by the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland (BAI), the research was undertaken by the Institute for Future Media, Democracy and Society (FuJo) at Dublin City University (DCU) and was published today (16.09.21). 

Facebook, Google, Microsoft, Mozilla, TikTok, and Twitter are all signatories to the self-regulatory Code of Practice on Disinformation. CovidCheck is the third monitoring report commissioned by the BAI, and prepared by FuJo, on the implementation of the Code in Ireland.  

This report provides analysis of the 47 monthly transparency reports, submitted by the signatories to the Code between August 2020 and April 2021 in response to the European Commission’s June 2020 communication on tackling COVID-19 disinformation. This analysis is supplemented by Irish case studies focused on Facebook and TikTok, and a review of the signatories’ transparency regarding the use of AI and automation in fighting COVID-19 disinformation.    

The research found that while the code has proven a useful instrument in prompting signatories to respond to concerns about disinformation, there are shortcomings in relation to its implementation and scope. Researchers cited difficulties in assessing the timeliness, completeness, and impact of the actions undertaken by the signatories. The report sets out nine recommendations for more effective reporting and monitoring of disinformation. 

The report recommends that:  

  1. Reporting should be standardised, as far as possible, to ensure necessary and relevant information is provided in a manner that facilitates monitoring.  
  2. Signatories should provide clear definitions of relevant policies to combat disinformation, clear definitions of common terms, and how these terms are operationalised on their services. 
  3. Relevant stakeholders should introduce a framework to address disinformation in comments that is consistent with Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights and the principle of freedom of opinion. 
  4. Regarding platforms’ active users, clear parameters should be defined for the reporting of granular data about specific action areas and in relation to EU Member States. 
  5. Meaningful KPIs (key performance indicators) should be defined for the reporting of results and outcomes in relation to key areas including: content labels, content and account removals, factchecking and media literacy campaigns. In addition, signatories should report on their own efforts to measure the efficacy of these actions and provide data to independent researchers to verify that efficacy.  
  6. The commitment to an independent auditor should be implemented under the revised Code and that the signatories provide adequate funding and resources to support this position.  
  7. In order to verify the implementation of actions, standardised procedures should be agreed for future monitoring.  
  8. Signatories should report on their use of automated systems to combat disinformation, including an explanation of what systems are used, what languages are covered, what kinds of disinformation they are trained to detect, and what risk assessments have been conducted on the AI systems used to tackle disinformation. It is also recommended that the European Commission articulates the need for risk assessments related to disinformation in the strengthened Code. 
  9. Signatories should embrace the need for transparency and data-sharing with researchers, as well as expand and improve services that allow researchers to access data. It is also recommended that the European Commission creates a clear regulatory framework for accessing data for research on disinformation and expands the scope of its current proposal to include more stakeholders, including members of civil society organisations.  

“The Code of Practice on Disinformation offers a means for signatories to provide transparency about their efforts to combat disinformation,” said FuJo researcher, Dr Eileen Culloty. “Unfortunately, many critical shortcomings have not been addressed since the Code was adopted in 2018. This includes the lack of a standardised reporting system and a lack of clarity around whether user comments, which were often found to be a source of disinformation, fell under content removal policies.”

“The role of AI in content moderation is another area that needs to be addressed,” Culloty added. “We hope the findings and recommendations of this report contribute to the strengthening of the Code, including the development of robust procedures for reporting and monitoring.” 

The research for this report is part of a larger project implemented by the European Regulators Group for Audio-visual Media Services (ERGA) that is designed to assist the European Commission in monitoring the effectiveness of the Code. The BAI chaired the ERGA sub-group in 2019 and continues to play an active role in the group.  

Deputy Chief Executive of the BAI, Celene Craig added: “The importance of social media in our information ecosystem is continuing to grow and the need for increased oversight of, and accountability by, social media platforms is now accepted. Legislation underpinning this is progressing at national and European levels.”

“The BAI is playing a leading role in this process and is committed to supporting the establishment of an effective regulatory regime in Ireland that will serve the needs of Irish and European citizens,” Craig added. “The implementation of the Code is part of this process, and this experience will provide a useful reference point for future regulatory engagement with the signatories.  Work on the revised Code is underway and the BAI believes that the analysis and recommendations in CovidCheck can make a valuable contribution to this process.” 

Watch the researchers Presentation here 

Download the report here 





FEATURES & INTERVIEWS
“I just think it's a voice that's so funny and criminally underused;” Deadly Cuts director Rachel Carey on the need for more working-class female-led comedies
Filming underway in Galway on new Irish drama series North Sea Connection
Free Industry Newsletter
Subscribe to IFTN's industry newsletter - it's free and e-mailed directly to your inbox every week.
Click here to sign up.






 
 the Website  Directory List  Festivals  Who's Who  Locations  Filmography  News  Crew  Actors
 

Contact Us | Advertise | Copyright | Terms & Conditions | Security & Privacy | RSS Feed | Twitter

 

 

 
bodrum escort bayan escort antalya gumbet escort